Dilettante's Diary

Dec 19/12

Who Do I Think I Am?
Index: Movies
Index: Writing
Index: Theatre
Index: Music
Index: Exhibitions
Artists' Blogs
Index: TV, Radio and Misc
MAY 27, 2024
Nov 3, 2023
Aug 2, 2023
July 4, 2023
Apr 21, 2023
Feb 10, 2023
Jan 24, 2023
Jan 11, 2023
Dec 2, 2022
July 26, 2022
July 4, 2022
June 2, 2022
March 25, 2022
March 11, 2022
Feb 14, 2022
Nov 19, 2021
Oct 2021
Sept 16, 2021
July 21, 2021
July 15, 2021
June 11, 2021
Apr 23, 2021
March 12, 2021
Feb 13, 2021
Jan 5, 2021
December 2020
Autumn Mysteries 2020
Aug 12/20
May 25/20
Apr 30/20
March 12/20
Dec 6/19
Jan 29/20
Nov 10/19
Oct 24/19
Sept 30/19
Aug 2/19
June 22/19
May 26/19
Apr 22/19
Feb 23/19
Jan 15/19
Dec 20/18
Dec 3/18
Oct 3/18
Sept 9/18
Aug 9/18
July 19/18
June 2/18
May 14/18
Apr 23/18
Feb 22/18
Dec 13/17
Nov 22/17
Nov 3/17
Oct 5/17
Sept 21/17
Aug 3/17
June 16/17
Mar 21/17
Feb 26/17
Feb 9/17
Jan 30/17
Dec 19/16
Dec 11/16
Nov 20/16
Sept 17/2016
Aug 21/16
July 17/16
June 29/16
June 2/16
Apr 23/16
Feb 28/16
Feb 1/16
Jan 27/16
Winter Reading 2016
Dec 15/15
Nov 19/15
Fall Reading 2015
Oct 29/15
Sept 16/15
Sept 4/15
July 29, 2015
July 1, 2015
June 7/15
Summer Reading 2015
May 19/15
Apr 30/15
Apr 19/15
Spring Reading 2015
March 23/15
March 11/15
Winter Reading 2015
Feb 20/15
Feb 8/15
Jan 29/15
Jan 20/15
Highs 'N Lows of 2014
Dec 19/14
Dec 2/14
Nov 10/14
Oct 29/14
Fall Reading 2014
Sept 17/14
Summer Reading 2014
Aug 22/14
Aug 8/14
July 11/14
June 16/14
May 28/14
Apr 30/14
Apr 16/14
Apr 2/14
March 21, 2014
March 13/14
Feb 11/14
Sept 23/13
Favourite Works: 2004-2013
Two Novels by BARBARA PYM
Sabbath's Theater by PHILIP ROTH
July 18/13
Summer Reading 2013
June 19/13
May 30/13
Spring Reading 2013
May 10/13
Apr 18/13
Mar 29/13
March 14, 2013
The Artist Project 2013
Feb 25/13
Winter Reading 2013
Feb 7/13
Jan 22/13
Jan 12/13
A Toast to 2012
Dec 19/12
Dec 16/12
Dec 4/12
Fall Reading 2012
Nov 17/12
Nov 6/12
Art Toronto 2012
Oct 23/12
Oct 4/12
Sept 28/12
Summer Reading 2012
Aug 26/12
Aug 8/12
Toronto Outdoor Art Exhibition 2012
July 14/12
June 28/12
May 27/12
May 20/12
May 4/12
La Traviata: Met's Live HD Version
Apr 21/12
Apr 6/12
Mar 22/12
Mar 9/12
The Artist Project 2012
Academy Awards Show 2012
Feb 26/12
Feb 11/12
Jan 23/12
Jan 15/12
Jan 7/12
Dec 20/11
Dec 12/11
Nov 27/11
Nov 18/11
Nov 7/11
Art Toronto 2011
Oct 22/11
Oct 17/11
Sept 30, 2011
Summer Reading 2011
Aug 11/11
July 28, 2011
July 19/11
TOAE 2011
June 25/11
June 20/11
June 2/11
May 14/11
Apr 29/11
Toronto Art Expo 2011
Apr 11/11
March 24/11
The Artist Project 2011
March 11/11
Feb 23/11
Feb 7/11
Jan 21/11
Jan 17/11
Dec 21/10
Dec 6/10
Nov 11/10
Fall Reading 2010
Oct 22/10
Summer Reading 2010
Aug 9/10
Aug 2/10
TOAE 2010
July 16/10
The Shack
June 27/10
June 3/10
May 5/10
April 17/10
Mar 28/10
Mar 17/10
The Artist Project 2010
Toronto Art Expo 2010
Feb 22/10
Feb 3/10
Notables of '09
Jan 11/10
Dec 31/09
Dec 17/09
How Fiction Works
Nov 24/09
Sex for Saints
Nov 11/09
Oct 22/09
Oct 6/09
Sept 18/09
Aug 23/09
July 31/09
July 17/09
Toronto Outdoor Art Exhibition 2009
Toronto Fringe 2009
Zen Wrapped In Karma Dipped In Chocolate
June 28/09
June 6/09
Myriad Mysteries 2009
May 10/09
CBC Radio -- "The New Two"
April 14/09
March 24/09
Toronto Art Expo '09
March 1/09
The Jesus Sayings
Feb 8/09
Jan 26/09
Jan 10/09
Stand-outs of 2008
Dec 24/08
Dec 4/08
Nov 16/08
Oct 27/08
Oct 16/08
Sept 26/08
Sept 5/08
July 21/08
Toronto Outdoor Art Exhibition 08
July 5/08
June 23/08
June 4/08
May 18/08
May 4/08
April 16/08
March 26/08
Head to Head
Feb 26/08
Feb 13/08
Jan 30/08
Jan 17/08
Notables of 2007
Dec 30/07
Dec 8/07
Nov 22/07
Oct 25/07
Oct 4/07
Sept 18/07
Aug 29/07
Aug 8/07
Summer Mysteries '07
July 20/07
June 28/07
June 8/07
May 21/07
May 2/07
April 14/07
March 23/07
Toronto Art Expo 2007
March 8/07
Feb 16/07
Feb 2/07
Jan 24/07
Notables of 2006
Dec 27/06
December 11/06
November 28/06
Nov 8/06
October 14/06
Sept 22/06
Ring Psycho (Wagner on CBC Radio)
Sept 6/06
August 12/06
July 18/06
June 27/06
June 9/06
May 23/06
Me In Manhattan
May 2/06
April 12/06
March 17/06
March 9/06
Feb 16/06
Feb 1/06
Jan 11/06
Dec 31/05
Dec 12/05
Nov 25/05
Nov 4/05
Oct 24/05
Sept 7/05
Sept 16/05
Sept 1/05
Aug 10/05
July 21/05
Me and the Jays
July 10/05
June 15/05
May 18/05
April 27/05
April 18/05
April 8/05
March 21/05
Feb 28/05
Feb 21/05
Feb 4/05
Jan 28/05
Jan 19/05
Jan 5/05
About Me
Dec 20/04
Dec 5/04
OTHER STUFF: Art Exhibitions, Concerts, etc.
The date that appears above is the date of the most recent reviews. As new reviews are added, the date will change accordingly. The new reviews will appear towards the top of the page and the older ones will move further down. When the page is closed, the items will be archived according to the final date on the page.

Reviewed here: A Late Quartet (Movie)
A Late Quartet (Movie) written by Yaron Zilberman and Seth Grossman; directed by Yaron Zilberman; starring Philip Seymour Hoffman, Christopher Walken, Catherine Keener, Mark Ivanir, Imogen Poots; with Madhur Jaffrey, Liraz Charhi, Wallace Shawn, Anne Sophie von Otter

You’ve got some of today’s best screen actors as famous musicians who are working on Beethoven’s Quartet, Opus 131, one of the supreme achievements of Western culture.

How could this movie not be good?

The script, that’s how.

Not that it starts off too badly. The cellist (Christopher Walken), the senior member of the quartet, finds that he has Parkinson’s Disease. He’s going to have to retire. That throws the rest of the quartet members into a tizzy. And here’s where the problems with the movie begin. The things that come up are banal and melodramatic. 

Especially in the case of the second violinist, Robert (Philip Seymour Hoffman). He decides that, since they’re going to be looking for a new cellist, he wants to shake things up even further: he’d like to alternate with the first violinist, Daniel (Mark Ivanir), taking turns in that role. Apparently Robert has been seething all these years with resentment. He thinks he’d make as good a first violinist as Daniel. Robert’s furious when his wife, Juliette (Catherine Keener), the violist in the quartet, won’t say unambiguously that he should be first violinist.

This crisis doesn’t ring true for me. There are hundreds of excellent musicians who have spent their entire careers quite happily as second violinists. I’m willing to grant that a few of them might prefer to have the first violinist’s role. But the script doesn’t make it the least bit believable that the Hoffman character would be one of them, that he would suddenly, after twenty-five years, dredge up this beef. As presented in this movie, the situation seems like nothing but a facile riff on the old slur about somebody playing “second fiddle.”

Other resentments that surface aren’t any more credible. Robert and Juliette have a daughter in her twenties. Alexandra (Imogen Poots) is a talented up-and-coming violinist who’s heading for a life as a professional musician. But now, as the shit starts to hit the fan, she decides to vent her anger about the fact that her mom’s career as a violist took her away from Alexandra as a kid. And this girl is herself looking to a career???

Those are just some of the klunkers that subvert the movie’s lofty intentions. At the beginning and the end of the movie, we see the quartet members on stage, elegant in their performing attire. You almost think the movie is trying to tell you: hey, these distinguished artists actually have pretty messy private lives, you know! It might be possible to make a good movie along these lines if the filmmakers in question had the artistic smarts to dig deep into the characters and come up with some genuine insight. Failing any such help from a script, the actors do their best with this material but it’s not easy to rise above lines like “Omigod, I can’t believe this is happening,” and “I made a mistake.” Somebody at one point says that the quartet has played 7,000 concerts in twenty-five years. I’m embarrassed to admit how long it took me to do the math on that one. Long enough, let’s say, to miss several more pages of blah-blah-blah

In respects other than the dialogue, the style of the film-making can only be described as earnest but plodding. When sexual hanky–panky’s in the offing, you can see it coming ten pages beforehand. (And, by the way, don’t ever try to get away with anything when that Juliette character’s around; the woman has the most uncanny knack for discovering incriminating evidence.) At one point, the movie tries to build great drama into the appearance of someone unexpected at Alexandra’s door, but you know the caller’s identity long before the camera finally shows the person. At another big “reveal” about a secret that’s supposed to be chilling, the moment was so clumsily broached that the audience laughed.

But I had the feeling that, at the Sunday matinee I attended, the good-sized audience – elderly and European, for the most part – was basking in the gratifying feeling of watching something very “cultured” and non-Hollywood. Admittedly, the movie does look good, almost Bergman-esque. The scenes are photographed in a painterly way. The clutter inside Alexandra’s apartment is so artfully arranged that I kept noticing lovely still life painting opportunities. Central Park in NYC looks good in snow and winter sunshine. We visit brownstones with gorgeous wood-panelled interiors. There’s even a trip to an art gallery for loving homage to a Rembrandt self-portrait. The American cultural luminary, Wallace Shawn, makes a cameo appearance to add a touch of class. And we get about thirty seconds of lieder from the esteemed Swedish soprano Anne Sophie von Otter. 

Some of the other audio elements aren’t so felicitous, however. Seeming to guess that the dialogue probably isn't enough to stir our emotions, the filmmakers have forced on us -- at almost every point when the quartet isn’t practising -- an intravenous drip of schmaltzy music. In most movies, that would hardly be objectionable but, in this case, it makes a nauseating juxtaposition with the Beethoven.
Among the actors, someone who makes a surprisingly favourable impression is Madhur Jaffrey in the cameo role of the doctor who first diagnoses the Walken character’s disease. An older woman, with dark hair and eyes, handsome, well-groomed, she looks middle-Eastern. (Turns out she’s from India.) There’s something about her – a warmth, a thoughtfulness, a calm – that startles you into thinking:  here’s a real person on screen. Unfortunately, Catherine Keener has no chance to show any of the off-beat charm and humour that have made her such a welcome presence in most of her movies. Mark Ivanir, in the role of Peter, is supposed to be a controlling, anal pill. He is. Imogen Poots pouts prettily but it’s not her fault that she can’t make sense of the Alexandra character. Christopher Walken, as the one who is withdrawing from the quartet, has the advantage of stepping back from the fray. There’s a certain fragile and tremulous dignity about him as he starts measuring his medications and learning to deal with his condition. As a teacher of music students in some college or university, he has a fine scene where he tells a story about an experience with Pablo Casals.  It’s hard to tell whether or not the story is true, but you wish it was.

As usual, Philip Seymour Hoffman is a phenomenon. He’s particularly outstanding in a scene that I’ll identify simply – in order not to give away too much – as the prelude to a violin auction at Sotheby’s. In his screen career to date, Mr. Hoffman has demonstrated the most uncanny knack of convincing you of the truth and sincerity in a wide variety of characters. I’m reminded of the saying that being a good actor means being a good liar. (I seem to remember that Marlon Brando said something like that in a Dick Cavett interview.) Mr. Hoffman can take any lines, written by anybody, and make you think that they are coming spontaneously from his own heart. I’d hate to think what it would be like to be involved with an actor like this in any personal way. You’d never know whether or not the things he professed with such conviction were any true indication of what he was feeling or thinking.

That’s 280 concerts a year, by the way.

Capsule Comment (instead of a rating): Soap opera dressed up as high culture.

You can respond to: patrick@dilettantesdiary.com